The New Era of Bitcoin ETF Competition Begins
Asset management giant BlackRock ($2.4T AUM) ignited fresh competition in spot Bitcoin ETFs by filing registration documents (Form S-1) with the SEC on June 15 for its proposed iShares Bitcoin Trust. Nasdaq simultaneously submitted a 19b-4 filing requesting rule changes to list the product. This dual submission marks a strategic departure from typical staggered filings.
Key Implications:
- Bitcoin prices surged 20% following the announcement
- GBTC's discount to NAV narrowed from 43.8% to 31.6%
- Competing funds like Ark 21Shares accelerated their filings
The SEC Approval Process Demystified
Phase 1: Initial Filings
Registration Statement (Form S-1)
- Filed under Securities Act of 1933
- Unlike most ETFs using Investment Company Act of 1940
Exchange Rule Change (Form 19b-4)
- Requires federal register publication
- Triggers 240-day review clock upon publication
👉 Why institutional investors are betting big on crypto ETFs
Phase 2: Review Timeline
| Stage | Duration | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Initial | 45 days | SEC first response deadline |
| First Delay | 45 days | Potential postponement |
| Second Delay | 90 days | Additional review period |
| Final | 60 days | Last postponement opportunity |
Critical Note: The clock only starts when published in the Federal Register - which hasn't occurred yet for BlackRock's filing.
Competitive Landscape Shifts
Ark 21Shares Bitcoin ETF
- Refiled on May 15 with enhanced SSA provisions
- Next SEC decision deadline: August 13
- Revised 19b-4 includes crucial surveillance sharing agreement
Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC)
- Pending lawsuit against SEC
- Oral arguments completed March 7
- Expected ruling fall 2023
- Conversion would eliminate current NAV discount
Market Impact Analysis
Price Momentum
- Bitcoin's 20% surge reflects institutional confidence
- GBTC discount narrowing signals ETF anticipation
First-Mover Advantage
- BITO controls 93% of Bitcoin futures ETF market
- Similar dominance expected for spot ETF approval
👉 How Bitcoin ETFs could reshape crypto markets
FAQ: Addressing Key Questions
Q: How likely is BlackRock's ETF to get approved?
A: While BlackRock has a 99.6% ETF approval rate, SEC has rejected 28/28 spot Bitcoin ETFs historically. Enhanced SSA provisions improve chances but don't guarantee approval.
Q: What's the timeline for a decision?
A: The 240-day clock starts after Federal Register publication. Expect multiple postponements based on historical patterns.
Q: How does this affect GBTC investors?
A: Positive ETF sentiment has already reduced GBTC's discount. Conversion would likely eliminate it entirely through creation/redemption mechanisms.
Q: Why are surveillance agreements so important?
A: SEC views them as critical for detecting/manipulation prevention. Previous rejections cited inadequate market oversight provisions.
Conclusion: Cautious Optimism Advised
While BlackRock's entry marks a watershed moment, regulatory hurdles remain substantial. The SEC's recent feedback about "unclear surveillance agreements" suggests continued scrutiny. Market participants should prepare for:
- Extended review processes
- Potential additional requirements
- Possible interim price volatility
The coming months will prove pivotal for institutional crypto adoption through regulated investment vehicles.